You Can’t Pick and Choose the Words of Jesus

Mountain path split in two with text overlay: “You can’t pick and choose what words of Jesus you’ll follow.”
Just like you can’t be a little bit pregnant, you can’t pick and choose which of Jesus’ words you’ll follow…
John 8:31 says:
“To the Jews who had believed him, Jesus said, ‘If you hold to my teaching, you really are my disciples.'”

Let’s put that into context.

I like the Message Bible here because of its conversational tone. In this passage, Jesus wasn’t being attacked or challenged. The Jewish crowd was asking questions, not questioning Him. He answered with clarity, not confrontation.

“When you raise up the Son of Man, then you will know who I am—that I’m not making this up, but I’m speaking only what the Father taught me. The One who sent me stays with me. He doesn’t abandon me. He sees how much joy I take in pleasing him.”

When he put it in these terms, many people decided to believe.

Then Jesus turned to the Jews who claimed to believe in him. ‘If you stick with this, living out what I tell you, you are my disciples for sure. Then you will experience for yourselves the truth, and the truth will free you.’”

— John 8:28–32, The Message

Many people admire Jesus. Maybe you do too. His teaching on love, compassion, and mercy is inspiring. His call to forgiveness and grace rings true.

But here’s where the tension comes in. Some want to stop there. They’d rather skip over His harder sayings. They’d rather ignore anything that sounds too sharp, too inconvenient, or too challenging.

That won’t work.

It’s impossible to be a selective follower of Christ. You can’t take the comfortable parts of His teaching and brush the rest under the carpet. Either you follow Him, or you don’t. You’re either His disciple or you’re simply a fan.

If you want to experience true freedom—deep freedom in body, soul, and spirit—you must take Jesus at His word. Believe Him. Follow Him. Obey Him.

When you do, you’ll find a freedom in your heart and emotions you never thought possible.

Until next time,

©2025 Katherine Walden

Want to stay in the loop? Sign up for my weekly email! Each message includes:

A devotional from me

That’s it—no spam, no extra emails, and your info stays safe. I use this list only for what I’ve promised.

Dear Friends,

Every year I need to cover the cost of keeping this website and domain online.
If this ministry has encouraged you, would you consider helping with this expense?
Your support makes it possible for me to keep sharing encouragement on this website and other outlets.

💙 You Can Help By Clicking Here

Share this article with your friends
Share